28.10.2026 · issue 3
It Is Not the Age. It Is the Rounds.
Most buyers ask a horse's age before anything else. I checked three years of results to see how much that age is worth. From 1,45m up, the answer is almost nothing. I am looking at a nine-year-old mare right now. Over the last year she has jumped 1,35m, 1,40m and 1,45m, and she is around fifty percent clear across all of them. The numbers climb as she goes up, not down. She came to 1,45m late. She has jumped 1,50m at one show, and that is all. People ring me asking for an eight-year-old already jumping 1,50m. At nine, they expect more than one show at the height. Sometimes a lot more. Here is what the data says about that.
What I did
Every international round scored on penalties, August 2023 to July 2026. Clear means zero faults. "Rounds at a height" means rounds at that exact height. Eleven rounds at 1,45m means eleven times at 1,45m. Her 1,30m record does not count towards it. I tested everything below at each height from 1,30m to 1,60m on its own.
1. Rounds beat everything
Split horses only by how often they have jumped a height before. Height — Under 5 rounds · 5–11 rounds · 12–30 rounds
- 1,30m — 43,1% · 48,0% · 49,3%
- 1,35m — 40,2% · 46,2% · 49,1%
- 1,40m — 33,4% · 39,3% · 43,1%
- 1,45m — 23,8% · 29,6% · 33,9%
- 1,50m — 21,7% · 27,9% · 32,0%
- 1,55m — 19,3% · 26,5% · 30,9%
- 1,60m — 16,7% · 23,4% · 28,9%
At 1,45m, a horse with under five rounds there goes clear 23,8% of the time. Twelve to thirty rounds: 33,9%. Ten percentage points. At 1,60m the gap is twelve. Every height. Every age group. Nothing else in this issue is as consistent. One caveat. Horses reach thirty rounds at a height because they cope there, so the size of the gap is flattered. The direction is not in doubt. That flattering effect has a name, and it matters even more in the next section.
2. Age only shows up below the ranking classes
I expected a flat line here. I did not get one. Take horses with the same experience — five to eleven rounds at the height — and split them by age. Height — Age 8–9 · Age 13–15 · Gap
- 1,30m — 50,8% · 41,9% · 8,9
- 1,35m — 47,6% · 43,5% · 4,1
- 1,40m — 41,3% · 37,1% · 4,2
- 1,45m — 30,1% · 29,7% · 0,4
- 1,50m — 28,1% · 28,4% · −0,3
At 1,30m, eight- and nine-year-olds go clear nearly nine points more often than horses of thirteen to fifteen. By 1,45m that gap is four tenths of a point. At 1,50m it is gone. Why? Because an older horse still at 1,30m is usually there for a reason.
Selection. In horse terms: the horses you see at a height are not a random draw from the yard. They are the ones that got there and stayed. A fourteen-year-old still jumping 1,30m and an eight-year-old passing through on the way up are two different kinds of horse, not the same horse at two ages. The limit: selection explains the gap across the whole group. It tells you nothing about which individual horse is which. At the ranking heights that sorting has already happened. Everyone there is a horse that made it, so the age labels stop meaning much. I stopped the list at 1,50m on purpose. Eight- and nine-year-olds at 1,55m and 1,60m are rare — a few hundred rounds in three years — too few to read a gap from. From 1,45m up, age tells you almost nothing about clear rounds.
3. Recent rounds beat career rounds
This is the one I did not see coming. I play golf. If I go out three or four times over a whole winter, I play badly. Three or four rounds in one week and I play well. Horses are the same. Here are horses at 1,45m that all have between six and fifteen career rounds at the height. The only thing that changes is how many of those came in the last twelve months. Rounds at 1,45m in last 12 months — Clear rate
- None — 18,4%
- 1–4 — 21,8%
- 5–10 — 28,0%
- 11 or more — 32,4%
Same career. Fourteen points apart, purely on how recent the work is. Now flip it. Take two horses at 1,45m. One has six to fifteen career rounds there, eleven or more of them in the last year: 32,4% clear. The other has sixteen or more career rounds, but only one to four recently: 30,1%. Fewer rounds. Better horse on the day. Hold recent rounds fixed and vary the career total instead, and at 1,45m it moves the clear rate by under eight points. Recent work counts for close to twice as much. Experience fades. A horse with ten rounds spread over five years is not an experienced horse at that height. Count rounds at the height in the last twelve months. That is the number.
4. The rider's ceiling shows up in the horse's record
At 1,50m, a horse whose rider also tops out there clears 9,0%. A horse whose rider jumps higher elsewhere clears 27,6%. Three times. The same pattern holds lower down: 12,9% against 31,3% at 1,45m, and 19,9% against 39,0% at 1,40m. Some of that is riding and some is that riders with headroom sit on better horses. The data cannot split the two. Either way, the same record means something different depending on who made it.
5. At 1,60m, the effect mostly runs out
Seven hundred horses with eight or more rounds at 1,60m. Their first three rounds: 23,6% clear. Rounds eight to twelve: 24,1%. Almost nothing. I would not say horses cannot learn 1,60m. I would say we rarely see mileage there turn into better results. By that level most of the learning has already happened.
What to do with this
Count rounds, not birthdays. At 1,45m and above, age tells you very little once you know how often a horse has been there. Weight recent rounds heavier. Eleven in the last twelve months beats sixteen spread across a career. A short record is short, not bad. First rounds at a new height are rarely clear, for horse or rider. Read the rider's ceiling next to the horse's record. Below the ranking classes, an older horse still at a small height is worth a second look — not because age hurts, but because horses that were going to move up usually have.
My take
Back to the mare. Her 1,50m record looks ordinary. Thirty-three percent, and one round of twelve faults in twelve months. That round came at 1,50m, early, under a rider new to the height. And that is the whole story of why she is "late." Her rider mostly produces younger horses. At 1,45m and 1,50m they have limited mileage, and above 1,50m almost none — a handful of international rounds in years. The mare did not arrive late because she is slow. She arrived late because nobody took her. She is one horse, not a pattern. But I have had ten-year-olds starting 1,50m late for the same reason, held back by the rider in front of them, and they turned into proper sport horses. On price, some of the premium is fair. An eight-year-old already jumping 1,50m gives you two more years than a ten-year-old with the same record. That is worth paying for. But only some of it. A year or two of delay costs almost nothing in clear rounds — that much the numbers do say. And the extra years are not guaranteed either. Some horses stop at eleven or twelve. Others are still jumping at the top at sixteen, seventeen, eighteen, if they are managed well. None of this replaces going to see the horse. The data widens the net — without it you only ever see what your own network offers you. Height, age, clear percentage, who is riding, how recently. That takes me from thousands of horses to a list worth driving to. Everything after that is still horsemanship.
That is the full scope. See you soon. Florian P.S. The Show Jumper has a free account. Pull up a horse you're looking at, count its rounds at the height in the last twelve months — not its age, not its career total — and see whether your read on it changes.
Notes
What is counted. Classic show jumping rounds scored on penalties. Point-scored, puissance and six-bar classes excluded. Period. August 2023 to July 2026. The recency test reaches back to 2018 so career totals are real career totals. First rounds only. Jump-offs excluded — only clear horses reach one, so including them would flatter every experienced horse. Withdrawals excluded. Eliminations and retirements count as not clear. Rounds at a height means that exact height, not across all heights. Age follows the FEI convention: a horse turns a year older on the 1st of January. Every finding was tested at 1,30m through 1,60m separately. International rounds only. This issue needs the same horse tracked across years, which I can only do reliably in international data. Source: The Show Jumper results database, pulled 14.10.2026.
